Post-termination restrictions: protecting your business when employees leave

Post-termination restrictions_ protecting your business when employees leave

Losing a key employee can expose a business to far more than the cost and disruption of recruitment. Client relationships, confidential information, business goodwill and even the stability of your workforce can all be placed at risk.

Post-termination restrictions can be a valuable tool for protecting those business assets. However, their effectiveness depends upon careful drafting and appropriate use. In this article, Charlotte Buck examines what post-termination restrictions are and how employers can use them effectively to protect their business when employees move on.

What are post-termination restrictions?

Post-termination restrictions (sometimes called restrictive covenants) are contractual provisions designed to protect an employer’s business by restricting certain activities of a former employee after their employment has ended. The most common types include:

Non-compete clauses

These prevent a former employee from working for, or setting up, a competing business for a specified period of time after leaving.

Non-solicitation clauses

These restrict a former employee from approaching clients, customers, suppliers or other business contacts with whom they had dealings during their employment.

Non-dealing clauses

These go a step further by preventing a former employee from carrying out business with certain clients, even where the client approached the employee rather than the other way around.

Non-poaching clauses

These prohibit a former employee from inducing colleagues to leave the employer’s business.

Confidentiality clauses

Whilst confidentiality obligations often continue indefinitely, employers frequently reinforce these obligations in post-termination provisions to protect trade secrets and sensitive business information.

Are post-termination restrictions enforceable?

The starting point under English law is that post-termination restrictions are unenforceable as restraints of trade.  However, they may be enforceable where the employer can demonstrate that:

1.            The restriction protects a legitimate business interest; and

2.            It goes no further than is reasonably necessary to protect that interest.

What is a legitimate business interest?

A post-termination restriction cannot be justified solely on the basis that it restricts competition. Instead, it must be aimed at protecting a legitimate business interest recognised by the courts, most commonly customer connections and goodwill, confidential information and trade secrets, or the stability of the workforce.

Reasonableness is key

Once an employer has established that a restriction protects a legitimate business interest, the court will consider whether it goes no further than is reasonably necessary to protect that interest. In other words, the restriction must be proportionate to the risk it is seeking to address.

Importantly, reasonableness is assessed at the date the contract was entered into, not with the benefit of hindsight after the employment relationship has ended. Relevant factors include:

Duration

Generally, the longer the restriction, the more difficult it will be to justify. Restrictions lasting between three and twelve months are common, depending on the employee’s seniority and access to confidential information.

Geographic scope

Restrictions should generally be limited to the geographical area in which the employer genuinely operates. A nationwide restriction may be difficult to justify where a business has a purely local customer base.

Scope of activities

Restrictions should focus only on activities that create a genuine risk to the employer’s business. Broad wording attempting to prevent all involvement in a competing business may be difficult to enforce.

Employee’s role

The reasonableness of a restriction will often depend upon the employee’s role and level of responsibility. A restriction that may be perfectly reasonable for a director or senior executive could be wholly unenforceable if applied to a junior employee with little client contact or access to confidential information. One size rarely fits all.

Common drafting mistakes

Many restrictive covenants fail because they are drafted too broadly. Common examples include:

  • Applying lengthy restrictions to junior employees with no client relationships.
  • Seeking to prohibit all competition rather than targeting specific risks.
  • Failing to define which customers or contacts are protected.
  • Using standard precedent wording without considering the employee’s actual responsibilities.
  • Leaving restrictions unchanged after an employee is promoted.

Eight ways to strengthen your restrictive covenants

1. Tailor restrictions to the individual

Consider the employee’s role, seniority, level of client contact and access to confidential information.

More senior employees will generally justify broader protection than junior employees.

2. Keep restrictions no wider than necessary

Ask what risk you are actually seeking to prevent and draft the restriction specifically to address that risk.

A narrowly targeted clause is often more likely to be enforceable than a broad attempt to prevent all competition.

3. Define protected clients carefully

Rather than attempting to protect every customer of the business, consider limiting protection to clients with whom the employee had material dealings during a specified period before their employment ended.

Clauses are generally more likely to be enforceable where they are limited to customers, clients or service users with whom the employee had material dealings during a defined period before termination.

4. Don’t forget garden leave provisions

Garden leave clauses can provide a useful additional layer of protection by allowing the employer to keep an employee away from the business during their notice period whilst continuing to employ and pay them.

Garden leave can also reduce the period for which post-termination restrictions need to apply, making them easier to justify and enforce.

5. Ensure contracts are properly executed

Even the strongest restrictive covenants will be ineffective if they are not properly incorporated into the contract of employment.

Employers should ensure that contracts are signed before employment commences and that any subsequent amendments are clearly documented and agreed.

6. Be able to justify the restrictions

Employers should retain records explaining why particular restrictions were introduced. If a covenant is later challenged, contemporaneous evidence demonstrating the commercial risks the restriction was intended to address can be extremely valuable.

7. Review contracts following promotions

Restrictive covenants should not be a “set and forget” exercise. Contracts should be reviewed whenever an employee moves into a more senior position or takes on significant new responsibilities.

8. Ensure there is proper consideration for new restrictions

Where restrictive covenants are introduced after employment has commenced, employers should ensure the employee receives something of value in return, such as a pay rise, bonus, promotion or other benefit. Without valid consideration, the restrictions will be difficult to enforce.

How can Pinney Talfourd help?

Post-termination restrictions can be an effective way for employers to protect client relationships, confidential information and workforce stability when an employee leaves. However, their effectiveness depends on careful drafting and ensuring that restrictions are appropriate to the employee’s role and responsibilities.

To maximise the prospects of enforcement, restrictions should be tailored to the individual employee, targeted at genuine business risks and kept no wider than reasonably necessary. Regular reviews are also important to ensure they remain appropriate as the business evolves.

Taking a proactive approach to reviewing and updating restrictive covenants can help protect your business and reduce the risk of costly disputes when key employees move on.

Whether you need assistance drafting new restrictions, reviewing existing employment contracts or enforcing restrictive covenants, our experienced Employment team can provide clear, practical advice tailored to your business.

For further advice, contact your nearest Pinney Talfourd office on 0800 011 1195 or email .

More information

Feel free to contact our marketing team on 01708 229 444 or email

Want to know more?

Our expertise

Employment for Business

Navigating employment law can be one of the most complex challenges for any business. We offer clear, practical advice and support to help you manage…

Find out more

Charlotte Buck - Pinney Talfourd Solicitors

About the author

Charlotte Buck is an experienced employment solicitor. She graduated from the University of Bristol with a BA in English in 2003, before completing her Graduate Diploma…

Charlotte Buck

Senior Associate

01708 463 211

charlotte.buck@pinneytalfourd.co.uk